Referee's Report Form

In order to submit referee's report to EJSE's editorial board please fill out the following Referee's Report Form. 

Reviewer Details

Date:
Name:
Email:

Manuscript Details

Paper number:
Title:
Authors:

CONFIDENTIAL REPORT TO THE EDITOR

Your comments in the last section will be communicated anonymously to the authors. Please tick as appropriate and comment where necessary.

A. Questionnaire

1. Is the title a brief and accurate indication of the contents? If not, your suggestions for improvement would be welcomed. Yes
No
2. Is the abstract adequate? Yes
No
3. Are the conclusions relevant and valid? Yes
No
4. Should any parts be expanded for clarity? If yes, please indicate which in your comments. Yes
No
5. Should any parts be condensed or deleted? If yes, please indicate in your comments. Yes
No
6. Are the illustrations of good quality? Yes
No

B. General Assessment

Originality Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor
Technical quality Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor
Contribution to the field Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor
Organisation of material Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor
Clarity of presentation Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor
Grammar and spelling Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor

C. Recommendation

Publish as is
Publish after minor revision (no re-review)
Major revisions required (re-review required)
Do not publish

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS TO THE EDITOR (if any)



REPORT FOR TRANSMISSION TO AUTHOR(S)

Paper number:
Title:

General comments


Essential modifications


Reasons for rejection

 

 

Copyright © EJSE International Ltd., 2001. All Rights Reserved.